My impression of the US
Nationals figure skating competitions is that they are for selecting the
strongest international competitors for world championships.
And whoever the judges
think are the potentially strongest international competitors are then selected,
mostly from the results of GPS of the season and the result of last season’s
worlds.
If no one was
successful making the Grand Prix Finale, then they may choose from the performance of the Nationals
competition.
And the scores are
usually influenced by other country’s top winners’ scores.
I won’t say this is
the fact, but it’s my personal impression.
Ladies
Ashley Wagner
I was pretty sure
Ashley Wagner will get her second National title, because she won two gold
medals at GPS competitions and won silver at GPF, she was very successful.
I love her skating and
I thought her FP was the most interesting to watch.
Even with two falls,
all the other parts she skated perfectly. IMO.
I can’t believe she
had food poisoning a few weeks ago ? I
suppose she could not train for a while because of it, it’s amazing she skated as
great as she did. I think she deserved
the 1st place.
And I agreed with her PCS. Right now, she is a must
have International competitor in the USA.
Mirai Nagasu
I thought she did the
best in the Short program technically , and artistically. I can’t believe she had the flu while doing
it !! wow.
I really loved this performance, it was very
enjoyable. She has her own style of skating, so always something interesting to
watch.
For her Long program,
I love the music very
much ! It’s so wonderful this season,
many skaters using Camille Saint Seans
music .
When I first saw this
program, I thought the choregraphy was kind of not so interesting but maybe it
was still work in process at that time ?
I really loved this program in Nationals.
It’s so shame her
three triple jumps were UR.
Again , she
had flu, it’s very understandable that she couldn’t do the best she wanted due
to her illness and bad health condition. It may hard to focus well when you are
not in the best condition.
So taking
care of her health may be her most important challenge for next season. I love
her costume for the LP a lot. She became
really gorgeous.
Gracie Gold
I’m pretty sure she
will be one of the strongest USA competitors and a star in the future. It was
amazing come back from 9th at SP to 2nd overall ( 1st
at LP) skated clean program. She has
strong jumps, can do triple triple combo.
Artistically, I wasn’t really impressed with her movements. I could see
she is trying , but something unbalanced power with her hands and arms , and
her arms are often straight.
It would be
great if she changes her landing pose more gracefully, instead of straight
stiff look arms.
Overall impression was
she landed all the jumps cleanly but not so memorable for her performance and
music.
But she is still 17 years
old (?), so surely she will improve her artistic part. ( I hope )
I think she has charisma so hope her performance will not be only jumps .
I suppose mental pressure is the most tough part in the
competition , so this time she doesn’t go to world as a US champion, may help a little.
I wish her all the
best at 4CC and Worlds.
Samantha Cesario
Her Long program is my
favorite performance in this competition and one of the performances we both
love to watch again and again as well as Ashley’s LP and Mirai’s Both
programs.
Very beautiful!
She is new to me. Commentator said after 2
years of absence because of injury, an amazing come back.
She has a lot of artistic talent and potential
in the future, seeing her movements and expression.
I look forward to seeing her future
performance. Big impact.
Agnes Zawadzki
I love her costumes,
both SP and LP. She has triple triple
combo and this is her strongest part as competing. Her movements are getting
more naturally artistic than last season.
She was not artistic skater last season.
So we can not judge from just one season. There is improvement now.
Costumes
I also would like to write about costumes in
this Ladies event .
I’m impressed that
nowadays a lot of skaters wear gorgeous costumes, and I’m really happy seeing this.
Before it was only Sasha Cohen who was
wearing stunning gorgeous costumes in the USA.
So it’s a great change.
My favorite costumes
in this event
1. Agnes Zawadski’s both costumes
(SP & LP)
2. Ashley Cain’s LP costume
3. Mirai Nagasu LP
4. Ashley Wagner LP
5. Gracie Gold SP
6. Christine Gao LP
Men
This
men’s competition had a lot of surprises as well.
First
of all, Congratulations on all the medalists !
Max Aaron
I
must say, whether you like it or not,
what Max Aaron did was really amazing with clean program. Landed all the
jumps including two 4S. He does quads
like triples, looked easy.
As
for musicality, first time when I watched it, I wasn’t really impressed with
his artistry and almost got bored, but
when I watched second time, I noticed that he does have musicality and has a lot
of potential to improve.
His movements are not robotic, and many parts looked
natural .
Just the program was kind of
boring and need more impact I think.
Really
well deserved gold medal !
Alexander Johnson
He is my favorite skater in this competition. Wow, since Johnny Weir, in the USA skaters, he is the first person who I felt has such an amazing natural artistic talent, from the first time I saw him. I can’t believe why I didn’t know about him until now ?
His
skating is wonderful !!
Looking
at his movements, how naturally artistic and well balanced for strength and grace.
And his triple axel is awesome, flowing and smooth ! I really hope this kind of
wonderful artistic skater will succeed.
Best wishes !!!
USC2013 Alexander JOHNSON FS
USC2013 Alexander JOHNSON FS
Jeremy Abbott
Oh, my goodness . I
didn’t expect he would be out for Worlds even though he wasn’t successful this
season at GPS.
I thought USA needs him as an international competitor. Because he has been giving good impression to
judges for his Presentation part , so he can earn from it even if he doesn’t
have quad.
He was landing single
quads until 2009 – 2010 season and was receiving full credit from it but after
that, I’ve heard he had shoes issue and since then he has been struggling
landing quad. What happened to his quad
? It’s because of his age ? or has
injury?
Anyway, in present situation, seems like he doesn’t
have quad.
He may not be one of the
strongest contenders for Olympics podium, but he could be placed in the top 6
in worlds. Because Kozuka and Oda are not in worlds team.
I’m not sure how
International judges sees Max Aaron ‘s presentation part. He is a very speedy
skater and his quad salcow jumps look amazing.
International judges usually didn’t give high PCS for
newbies, so he will need to earn from his jumps and speed and energy and make a
big impact .
I also understand USFS
wants to send skaters who can land more than two quads in long program. Because
right now three quads , two quads combo are required in Long program to win
world title.
I think USFS is still
testing skaters before Sochi Olympics.
And they will decide based on the result of this year’s worlds and next
season’s GPS.
It looks to me , art
score is not really real art scores , because except for Daisuke Takahashi , I
feel all the other present top skaters’s PCS are incredibly overly scored if it’s scored
based on art.
There are skaters who
are just doing choreography ,and careless for how they are using their body and
expression, but receiving really high scores.
but what judges value for presentation parts are definitely different
from my views.
For Jeremy’s
programs, my husband and I both feel Jeremy is more match with upbeat, fun, dancing programs rather than
this kind of sentimental/ Lyrical type of program.
Because his slower programs always look the same kind of choreography.
I thought his movements for this
performance LP was much better than GPS’s performances. More natural and well
balanced moves. But I need more impact,
like his Masquerade program. Tom Dixon’s
choreography was really good for him. IMO.
Jason Brown
We remember him from
last year’s Nationals competition.
Wonderful music
selection!
I loooove this music
Liebestraum by Franz Liszt !!! and of
course he skated great with it. We both think he has his original style of skating and has big impact.
Very smooth and musical. His artistry is wonderful. We watched his Liebestraum performance so many times already.
Very smooth and musical. His artistry is wonderful. We watched his Liebestraum performance so many times already.
I don't know why, the more I watch his performance, the more interesting. I'm getting addition of his skating now.
We
really enjoy his performance almost everyday. We look forward to seeing his skating in Junior world championships.
Alexander Johnson and Jason Brown are my new favorite men's skaters.
Alexander Johnson and Jason Brown are my new favorite men's skaters.
Jonathan Cassar
I also
liked Jonathan Cassar’s skating. His
form of skating is beautiful to watch, and his jumps error didn’t bother me
much. Some part of his movements , spread
eagle from outside to inside and ina baur reminds
me of Jeffrey Buttle’s movements.
Ross
Miner
I was predicting he might possibly win the Nationals title this year
seeing the result of GPS or at least he will make the world team unless he
skated really badly.
And it’s great he made silver. He seems like really a
nice friendly person with good sportsmanship. He is more of technical skater
and his quad jump looks stable. I would love to see performance which has more
impact in artistry. Wishing he cares
more his movements and expression, by taking dance class.
Artistry is really subjective, and I wish Alexander Johnson type of skaters will be more
valued and will get higher PCS in future men’s skating. I look forward to seeing 4CC and World
Championships.
I
think Yuzuru, Daisuke, Javier, Patrick,
are the strongest contenders to be on the world podium this season.
Then, Florent, Kevin.R, Michal, Brian,
… If Max skated like this, he
may be possibly in the top 6 . Miner
also will be in the top 10.
Just my guess.