Skip to main content

Who are genuine artistic skaters ?


People’s views are always different especially when it comes to artistry.

I really think we all are biased for our favorites based on our taste, our views, our personalities, and it also might be coming from which side of the brain is more developed , right brain or left brain.

And whatever art or other things that we learn, there are always levels, whether it’s judges scoring by whatever the rules happen to be, which BTW the rules were made by people who also have their own bias and favorite type of figure skating, or it comes from laws of nature.
 
We can feel which pianists are playing from the heart or not, besides being able to appreciate the technical ability. 


In figure skating,

Genuine artistic skaters to me are

Johnny Weir
Emanuel Sandhu
Tatiana Navka
Oksana Baiul

These skaters come to my mind first.


The following are also genuine artistic skaters, 


Stephane Lambiel
Daisuke Takahashi
Staviski (of Denkova/Staviski)
Shen( of Shen & Zhao )
Tatiana Totmyanina/Maxim Marinin
Shizuka Arakawa
Yukina Ota

Then,
Alexie Yagudin,

Then, maybe

Evgeny Plushenko for some of his programs.


Depending on the program and Gala number, there are more to name. But mostly my first level, second level skaters I listed above , I usually enjoyed most of the programs they performed whether they skated good or bad.

* Expression
* Emotional level
* Creativity
* Body movements ( total balance)
* Choreography/ music composition
* Performance execution

* Interpretation
 
It’s slightly different from the menu of COP. 


Personally, I really care for skater’s expression, emotional level, body movements, creativity besides interpretation while watching figure skating.

Expression and emotional levels are all feeling. 




Here are my lists for men’s skaters.
Expression ( how naturally showing )

1. Emanuel Sandhu / Johnny Weir
2. Alexei Yagudin
3. Daisuke Takahashi
4. Stephane Lambiel
5. Evgeny Plushenko
6. Brian Joubert

 
Sandhu didn’t often show his artistic talent in the competitions because of his nerves, so it took a while to find his true talent after collecting many past skating events. 


Brian Joubert has been always under rated by many skating fans especially in the North American area, but I did feel his emotion with some of his programs ( for example, his Olympic FP. 

It was disaster for his jumps but I liked his artistry in it.) and it looked very natural and was imaginative.
 

Emotional level ( the deepest )

1. Johnny Weir / Emanuel Sandhu
2. Alexei Yagudin
3. Daisuke Takahashi
4. Evgeny Plushenko
5. Stephane Lambiel
6. Brian Joubert


The deepest emotion I felt was the skaters above.
For ladies, Oksana Baiul comes my mind first. Then Yukina Ota.
To me, Lambiel’s emotional level is not so deep, he has an amazing musicality, however he is not the best actor to me. Weir, Sandnu, Plushy’s performances often deleted Lambiel Gala Numbers and also until 2005 - 2006 season because mostly it came from his emotional level. I’m more enjoy watching his dance moves more than his story telling programs.

Creativity

1. Stephane Lambiel
2. Johnny Weir
3. Emanuel Sandnu

But Weir may be more creative recently, since he has been constantly creating his Gala numbers every season. 


And while I didn’t see Lambiel created new Gala number since his Romeo & Juliet. After that, he was doing his new FP at ice shows. I wonder what happened to him ?
 
Body movements ( total balance)

* Johnny Weir
* Emanuel Sandhu
* Stephane Lambiel
* Daisuke Takahashi
* Alexi Yagudin
* Evengey Plushenko

* Jeffrey Buttle
* Brian Joubert ( since 2008 season)
 
Body position & form, flexibility, sensitivity, line of movements, body language, using body, neck, shoulders, arms, hands, fingers which comes from the root of body.


Those all skaters I listed above also have their own style and have well-balanced movements.

I’m not into skaters who are just skating gracefully, all soft movements all the time with no balance and no ups and downs.
 
Brian Joubert’s butt shaking in the starting choreography in his present SP is off balance, because he is using his butt but if he uses his hips instead of his butt, it can be well- balanced. 
 
So as it is now, it looks hilarious.

For other parts, there are also a few parts , sometimes his movements get off balance, but mostly his movements are well-balanced, using his full body which are coming from the center of his body.

I also like his hands , the way how he uses look beautifully sharp. 

 
I like many kinds of styles of art , and beauty when it’s well-balanced. 

Brian Joubert is not a dancer however some of his movements reminds me of basic positions and forms doing Jazz dance. 
 
I don’t think he is just a jumper like many people are saying. Only in his Free program, because of less choreography compared with other skaters , he often looks just doing elements to elements. 


I think It’s more about stamina issue, to handle free program.

For Ladies,

I like Sasha Cohen’s skating especially for her passionate programs ( SP), very musical, and good balance of movements which has soft and sharp. 

And her stretch for her body, legs, arms are magically beautiful. 

Why she can make so well ? There are many flexible skaters out there, but not really magical like her. 
 
For her hands and fingertips movements, I’m not so crazy since she seemed to only care for that part of her artistry during 2004-2005 season. 
 
For her sentimental programs, her facial expression didn’t look so natural, but for her passionate programs, her facial expression looked more natural.

Shizuka Arakawa, I started liking her artistry since Olympics Gala. And I was not so crazy for her movements while she was an eligible skater.

Her true artistic potential seemed to blossom and appeared at ice shows where she can fully express her artistic world without having to worry about the judging system.

Her posture during the competitions was similar to Miki Ando. But people always point out only Miki for the posture.


For body movements,

I think in the present skaters, Mao Asada and Mirai Nagasu have great artistic balance of movements, they have ups and downs, soft and sharp with sensitive movements.

The way how Miki Ando uses her hands and fingers are often beautiful and sensitive, and also she is good at sharp movements and in this way similar to Sasha Cohen.
 
Many of ladies skaters are doing ballet style, graceful soft movements and no sharp movements with no originality but I think Miki Ando has unique artistry which is not ballet style. I really loved her SP during 2006-2007 season. 


Shizuka Arakawa’s soft movements are true beauty. I was very impressed with her performance when I saw her live, especially one of her spins, for the movements of her arms and hands and fingers.
It was magic. 
 
It’s different from Miki’s style. But I like them both.

There are more to write about artistry for skaters. 

But I need to do something else now , so I will write in my next post. 
 

Popular posts from this blog

Who was The Mysterious Masked Messenger who visited Mozart ?

Perhaps the most mysterious legend about Mozart is that of the " Masked Messenger ". This mysterious masked messenger is also known historically as the "Man in Gray" , "The Mysterious Messenger" , "The Gray Messenger". The story of the masked messenger was featured prominently in the movie “ Amadeus ".           Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart How much of this story is true ? When Mozart died in the early morning hours of December 5, 1791, he left his final masterpiece, the Requiem , unfinished. A few months later, a completed score of the Requiem was delivered to its anonymous commissioner. How was the Requiem completed and how would Mozart have completed it had he lived? These mysteries have tantalized musicians for over two centuries. Mozart received the commission to compose the Requiem from the “ Mysterious Messenger" in the summer of 1791.  The Messenger paid half the commission in advance,

Health tips from an extra-terrestrial named Bashar - from a planet called Essassani

photo credit: skyseeker Mt. Fuji via photopin (license)    Today,  I would like to write about health tips from an extra-terrestrial being named Bashar who is from the Essassani Planet .     He is channeled by Darryl Anka. Planet earth used to have beautiful clear air, but since a long time ago the air has been polluted everywhere.    and the cause of most illnesses comes from the poison in the environment we are in, with the polluted air. Nowadays, it's hard to find places where there is beautiful clean air. and in this unfavorable environment, he is suggesting how to live healthy.   Health tips 1.  Clear Oxygen  According to Bashar,  the air after storms and typhoons have gone away, is the most clean ( purified ) and is good for our bodies. However when there is an overdose of artificial oxygen by using tools such as oxygen tanks , this can cause a lack of water, and will weaken cells.   So clean natural water needs to be used in a balanced amo

Sweet Food which does not get fat - Warabi mochi

I recently love eating this sweet food that Japanese call " Warabi mochi " which is made of 0 calories food psyllium in my coffee break time.   It's sweet food but I use Lakanto Monk Fruit Sweetener instead of sugar when I make it. Lakanto Monk Fruit sweetener is 0 calorie s and 0 glycemic and very similar taste as normal sugar. It is said it's derived from monk fruit, which looks like a small green gourd native to regions of China and Thailand.  It's not artificial so it is not bad for health so I feel comfortable eating it. Warabi mochi is a food which is normally made of Kinako ( soybean flour) & sugar & warabi powder and it's one of my favorite foods. However it's high calorie foods so if I eat a lot, it's easy to gain weight.   Because Warabi mochi flour is Starch and has sugar in it and is high calorie.  So I was not eating it. and then recently I found the recipe of diet Warabi Mochi which is made of Psyllium

Beauty skin care, Ninon de L'Enclos ‘s Secret of her young skin

Besides extra virgin olive oil, I’ve been doing a mixture of another great natural formula since two weeks ago. This information came from Ray who happened to find about Ninon de L’Enclos ’s amazing story concerning her youthful skin. According to the article, Ninon de L’ Enclos is known as a famous French beauty from the late 1600s. She kept her youthful skin until 85 years old when she passed away. Even in to her 80’s she was attracting many young men who fell hopelessly in love with her. She never published her secret of her youthful skin until the end , only telling her special friends about her secret formula. There is no photo of her, but seeing her painting in other websites, she looks in her 30’s when she was 85. According to the article, her face was as smooth and free of winkles in her 80’S as it had been at 20. She hated wrinkles and successfully kept her skin youthful , using her special secret formula. This information blew me away, and immediately

Franz Liszt and Frederic Chopin’s friendship Part 1

Frederyk Chopin   I’m a long time fan of Chopin’s music since when I was a teenager. Started loving his music from hearing his Polonaise , then Noctunes , Etudes … Frederyk Chopin I was using one of Chopin’s Nocturnes as my background music for my answering machine when I was in my 20s. In Japan, many of his music is famous and used in many TV dramas, commercials, movies, and mostly wealthy bourgeois family scenes. My image of many of Chopin ’s music that I’ve listened to is of a cozy, bourgeois world. From almost all his music I’ve ever heard, I often pictured an elegant, wealthy family’s world or a story about a family who are living in a luxury antique style house. Many of Mozart ’s music reminds me of a social life in an older generation, a story about bourgeois world in a gorgeous luxury palace. For Liszt ’s music, his music is very variety, ranging from an image of a sweet passionate love story for couples, all the way to nightmare horror story type of mu

Franz Liszt’s dangerous love

  Franz Liszt was quite tall in his generation, standing 6 feet 2 inches tall , long blonde hair , piercing sharp eyes, pianist' long narrow and delicate hands and fingers. His body build was very slender. People who knew him described his personality as full of charm, charisma, and very knowledgeable.  And he loved brainy women. He was the consummate artist. It seems that Liszt loved dangerous love , which thrilled him and gave him excitement rather than a stable, peaceful , safe love. Franz Liszt While reading about his biography, I was wondering why he fell in love with two princesses who were already married. Marie D’Agoult He seems to have had a lot of love affairs in his life, someone found out that he had at least 26 serious relationships in his life ( besides countless other affairs ) but the only ladies he thought about marriage was with these two princesses , Marie D’Agoult and Carolyne Sayn Wittgenstein ? Charlotte Von Hagn L

My favorite ways of Law of Attraction Part 3 - Successful Wishing - Pierre Franckh

Pierre Franckh’s books “ Successful Wishing “ are another of my favorite books.     There are series, 1 to 6 , and are not published in English , but I did find them in a Japanese book store,  translated by a Japanese translator.   Pierre Franckh is a German actor ( Movies & TV) from 1959 – 2003, and is also a movie director and a writer.  Since 1996, he published many books and became a best selling author.  Franckh wrote based on his personal experiences from when he was a child . I love the way how he writes , it’s very easy to read and direct to the point, very clear how to do it with step by step instruction. Also importance of finding what you truly want.    Many people are actually not realizing what they really want and then when they get what they wanted,  still not feeling satisfied. Pierre said that before making your wishes and order to universe, it’s important to clear up what you really want and ask to yourself, why you w

Organic foods and healthy living “ You are what you eat ? “

We‘ve been enjoying organic foods since a month ago.   Because we care for our health and also organic foods taste more delicious than normal vegetables.   Recently, I really feel the famous quote  “ You are what you eat . “   is true.   Although healthy life comes from balance between mind, body, skin care, good night sleep and activities besides food life .   Health is a treasure.   Also I realized that “ good blood circulation ” is one of the most important key to keep healthy and look young skin.   After being amazed to see Styx’s ageless Tommy Shaw on TV, I started searching about “ secret of youth “.  He looks so much younger than his age.  Also, there was an interview with Styx on CNN in the morning about a week ago and they talked about what they think are the keys to longevity and a healthy life. http://www.cnn.com/video/?/video/bestoftv/2012/04/23/exp-kyra-phillips-age-against-the-machine.cnn  

”The secret to creativity is knowing how to hide your sources.” - Albert Einstein 

Originally we were all creative because all children are creative. While growing up, many children lose their creativity by seeing, reading, hearing what many grown ups do and teach. According to a book called " Goal " by Brian Tracy, "Fully 95% of children tested between the ages of three and five are rated as highly creative. Of the same children tested again as teenagers, only about 5% rated  as highly creative. What happened to them in the interim ?   As they went through school, they were taught that if you want to get along, you follow the crowd. They learned not to question or challenge the teacher or to suggest unusual ideas. In their attempts to be liked and accepted by their peers, they allowed their creativity to die down, like a fire without fuel.  " "All children are artists. The problem is how to remain an artist once they grows up."  -  Pablo Picasso But if we don't use creativity, we lose it. It means that the more we use cre

Charm of Kenichi Hagiwara - Shoken

From Japanese Movie " Ame no Amsterdam (Rain in Amsterdam)" I've been into the late 1960s to 1970s generation since several years ago. I don't know why but I'm very interested in older generation's people, trends, lifestyle, scenery, habit, TV drama, music, films, etc..   and not so interested in new things much.  There are many new discoveries through checking out old stuff while reading and watching it, which I didn't know before. and about several months ago, I happened to find a youtube video of  a famous Japanese actor called Kenichi Hagiwara who was my favorite actor in 1970s when I was a kid. His nickname is Shoken and he is also a singer of Rock/blues music.                      Shoken( 18 years old) singing ”Legend of Emerald” Shoken was one of the super stars in Japan mainly from the late 60s generation to early 80s. When he was 15 years old,   he joined an amateur music group band called The Tempters as a vocalist.   A